The Hold Steady

Boys and Girls in America (Vagrant Records 06) Rating: A-
With critical acclaim accompanying Almost Killed Me (2004) and Separation Sunday (2005) and this album appearing on many year-end top 10 critic lists along with "early Bruce Springsteen meets Thin Lizzy" descriptions, I just had to check these guys out. After all, those are two of my all-time favorite artists, and though this album doesn't quite rise as high as Bruce or Lizzy at their best, it has more than lived up to my high expectations. For one thing, it smartly clocks in at a manageable 40-minute length, containing a mere 11 tracks, none of which are worse than good and several of which are outstanding. Rapid fire riffs that stick, dual guitar harmonies a la Lizzy, appealingly bright keyboard colorings, a rocking rhythm section, and group leader Craig Finn's oft-quotable, story-based lyrics about assorted teenage drunks and druggies are this albums primary selling points. He's not a great singer by any means, and in fact his one-note range wears a bit thin over the course of the entire album, but there are quite a few catchy sing along choruses and even a beer soaked ballad or two for variety's sake. Finn's lyrics are nothing if not wordy and literate, not unlike early Springsteen, whose early vocal style his talk-singing most recalls. As such, it's fitting that "Stuck Between Stations" strongly begins the album by referencing Jack Kerouc and paying tribute to poet/suicide victim John Barryman, and the catchy first single "Chips Ahoy!" tells a typically interesting story, this one about a girl who can't stop winning at the race track and spending her winnings on drugs. As for the other plentiful highlights, "First Night" is a stellar ballad (dare I call it a "power ballad"?), "Party Pit" and "Massive Nights" have some of the albums most memorable vocal hooks, "Chillout Tent" is enhanced by the lovely little girl vocals of Elizabeth Ellmore and another strong melody, and "South Town Girls" ends the album with a rousing, anthemic sing along. That said, having pointed out this albums clear highlights, what I appreciate most about Boys and Girls in America is the consistent high quality of its songs, the first rate musicianship of the band performing them, and the rich cast of characters who populate this album and whose struggles are always well worth following.

send me an email

Back To Artist Index Home Page